Security Chiefs Take Over Zimbabwe’s Economy
With security forces having seized control of economic and financial policy at a time of shrinking GDP and skyrocketing inflation, Zimbabwe is facing its worst crisis in more than a decade.
Basic goods are scarce and the value of the Zimbabwean dollar has continued to tumble, pushing official annual inflation to 785.6% in May and causing real incomes for Zimbabweans to evaporate.
The International Monetary Fund estimates that the economy will contract as much as 10,4% this year following a 12,8% contraction in 2019.
The Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) reintroduced the Zimbabwean dollar quasi-currency in June 2019 having unpegged from the United States dollar four months prior, but the currency depreciated rapidly.
RBZ governor John Mangudya unilaterally reimposed a dollar peg of $25 to the US dollar in March, only for the government to scrap it three months later in favour of a return to the auction system
Mangudya has issued a ban on some electronic money transfer services, with black market traders and electronic transactions a key source of currency devaluation.
The last time the RBZ called for money transfer providers and local capital markets to suspend operations indefinitely was in 2008, when Zimbabwe’s hyperinflation reached a world record 89.7 sextillion percent year-on-year.
A year later, the Zimbabwean dollar was scrapped.
Robert Besseling, executive director of political risk consultancy EXX Africa, suggested that in the next step to try to limit the damage, private bank accounts are “likely to be raided to fund a bailout that is mostly benefiting politically-connected business allies of the governing elite”.
Mangudya has claimed local banks have over US$1 billion in their accounts, which he hopes will help stabilise the local currency’s value.
“The blame for the collapse of the economy may be squarely placed on the mismanaged reintroduction of a local currency after 10 years of dollarisation, which has fostered fraud and embezzlement on a massive scale,” Besseling said in a report last week.
“Opposition activists have long accused (President Emmerson) Mnangagwa and his business allies of weakening the economy through covert foreign exchange dealings and over-priced procurement deals.”
On June 26, a Joint Operations Command (JOC) collective of security chiefs ordered the government to close the privately-owned Zimbabwe Stock Exchange and halt mobile money transfers, which host nearly all of the country’s commerce.
The move, taken after black market trading plunged the reinstated Zimbabwean dollar past 100 to the greenback versus the official rate of 57, blindsided the Finance ministry and the RBZ.
This effectively hijacked economic policy, EXX Africa highlighted, a clear show of frustration with Mnangagwa’s government’s handling of the ailing economy.
The government has taken aim at the private sector for the crisis, particularly mobile money platforms and the stock exchange, both which it has alleged are linked to illegal foreign exchange trading and money creation.
The ruling Zanu PF party is now embroiled in a tussle with insurance firm Old Mutual, which the government said it had “ejected” from the country’s financial system amid allegations of undermining the local currency.
The Old Mutual Implied Rate, used by some companies to transact business, uses the difference between the prices of Old Mutual’s shares on the Zimbabwe and London stock exchanges to predict the future rate of the Zimbabwean dollar.
Old Mutual has issued a statement assuring customers that all services and operations continue to “run as normal” and said it is “working with all relevant stakeholders to seek clarity on the matter,” as the government doubles down on assertions that it should be delisted from the Zimbabwe Stock Exchange
The RBZ in May began printing money in a bid to raise $720 million to prop up the country’s industrial sector, which sent the local currency plunging and inflation surging.
In late June, the Zimbabwean dollar devalued past 100 in some areas of the parallel foreign currency market, or black market, as demand for the US dollar intensified.
The country also faces food, fuel and medical equipment shortages due to a lack of hard currency to purchase imports. All of this comes at a time when Covid-19 infections are escalating in Zimbabwe.
“Even in a likely best-case scenario, Zimbabwe faces another round of hyperinflation that will collapse its economy, cause widespread starvation and social instability that threaten neighbouring countries, and the looming prospect of another military intervention in political power,” EXX Africa concluded in its report.
Zimbabwe is now among the four most food-insecure countries in the world alongside Yemen, Somalia and South Sudan, and EXX Africa analysts foresee this worsening along with high inflation and an economic recession, creating fertile ground for political instability and civil unrest.
Vice-President Constantino Chiwenga is now reportedly being prepared to assume authority, as his allies hope that mismanagement of the coronavirus, food insecurity and other socio-economic issues will force the ruling Zanu PF to remove Mnangagwa and install him as president.
“In preparation for an eventual power dispute, Zanu PF leaders are arming militias in the countryside, in a scene reminiscent of the years-long succession contest under Robert Mugabe in which Mnangagwa ultimately prevailed,” the EXX Africa report explained.
“The president now faces a similar challenge from armed militias running rampant in the ruling party’s heartlands, while his business allies are being undermined.”
While Besseling suggested that Mnangagwa will be able to see off any unconstitutional challenge so long as he can continue to pay military salaries, they suggested that the deterioration of the economy and public health may gradually weaken this prospect. — CNBC